Thursday, September 01, 2005

Some questions asked

An anonymous commenter has asked some questions that ought to be talked about. He/she may have meant them to be rhetorical but they are important questions nonetheless.

Increased investment would be great as well as Ukraine being a member of WTO. That being said it does matter who eventually benefits from the investment and more foreign owners will generate jobs

- hopefully more people will stay in the country as more jobs are available

People will stay. The reasons they are leaving is for the money. Some of the advertising here takes advantage of this. One subway poster for a company that allows for wire transfers of money is split into two panels. On the left is a woman setting a table--a waitress? a domestic?-- with a smile on her face. On the right is a young fellow sitting in what is obviously a college class looking rather wistfully--or is his look uncertain? "will it get here in time?"--into the camera. It's all about the money.

The question though is whether the diasporists will come back when things begin to pick up. Maybe if it reaches European levels, maybe. But you have to figure that people get their lives oriented a certain way and get set somewhere and that has to make it difficult to come back.

The big elephant in the room in all this is the movement of people from the villages to the big cities. Ukraine is one of the most rural countries in the world. Lots of people live in villages and there is a kind of culture linked to it. Everyone in the big city has someone they are related to or know who lives in the village. That has been an advantage in allowing them to eat during the bad times because they have had access to the produce of the village from those links.

The problem is that the villages are dying. There is no opportunity for the young people there, no business other than agriculture for them to be involved in. And the agriculture is monopolized by what are often no more than the old party bosses or the new capitalists that are indistinguishable from the old party bosses, who are farming the land non-productively and taking the cream for themselves. They just limp along providing nothing for the young to get involved in and no real economic benefit for the community.

And for those of us who are looking for ways to make the villages more productive, we are faced with three facts that stand in the way, booze, apathy and theft. A lot of village men spend a lot of time either drunk or looking for a drink. That gets in the way of doing something productive. In one village I am aware of, the men got together to set up a fishing business. They would stock a local pond with fish and charge for fishing. I was asked to invest but couldn't see how it would be an economic benefit for the community, how it would generate money and create jobs. The only people I could see who would want to fish there--at the equivalent of the local fishing hole--would be locals, the same people who need businesses to come in so they can have jobs to make money and provide opportunity for the young. This sort of arrangement didn't make the economic pie bigger, which is what is needed, it just rearranged it.

But they went ahead without me anyway and set it up. They sold their memberships to locals, about 72 of them representing most of the male population of the village. And they stocked the pond. Now, on a lot of days, you will find men getting up early to go fishing. They make their way down to the pond and fish?--no, they spend it drinking with a line dangling in the water. And they leave their wives home to work the land and harvest the crops.

Now I have heard that all the fish have died from some kind of a disease. It's hard not to say that it serves them right. But it does.

What will happen is that the young will leave for the big cities leaving the old for the villages. It is happening right now as a matter of fact. When these elderly villagers die off, that will be it. And the link between the village and the city, a link that saved many lives in Ukraine I am convinced, will be severed.

The cities will be hard pressed to deal with the influx of people. Where are they going to live? Housing prices in Kiev have skyrocketed the past couple of years making it unaffordable for a lot of people. They might be able to rent a room here or there but there will be a shortage of places to stay. In Latin America, the problem is solved with shantytowns, slums on the outskirts of town or up in the hills (Caracas.) Might be what Ukraine is faced with. I hope not.

Of course, the decline in the birthrate might solve some of this problem. But it will create another. Who will be around to generate the economic activity needed to take care of an aging population?

-but will the wages be livable?

They aren't livable now. The fortunate thing is that virtually no one is carrying a mortgage payment and energy rates are low and produce comes in from the village--the above linkage. But energy rates could rise to more European levels and that would affect a lot of people. One economist said that if that happened in Russia and mortgages became a much more accepted and common thing, people would be forced to mortgage their flats to pay for their energy consumption. It would put everything at risk. Something like this could happen here.

Western companies pay higher wages here and they provide better benefits on the whole. The low wages and poor working conditions have come on the Ukrainian watch. Incredible wealth has been amassed by a select few while the rest of the people have been scratching out some sort of existence at the wages offered by the companies of these moguls and "entrepreneurs." Looks like feudalism dies hard.

For Western companies, you can't oppress your workforce and end up with anything productive. That may be in their self-interest and nothing to canonize them about. But it does benefit the employee. And there is some conscience involved in this with some. Some people don't surrender their humanity just because they get involved in business.

and the owners will be the ones who ultimately benefit and will they invest in the country (spanning the spectrum from philanthropy to Gucci stores) or will it end up elsewhere?

Privatization in Russia and Ukraine meant capital flight and it still does to some extent. Most of the Western advisors promoted the idea that state companies should be in private hands-- any way they could get there was fine. The argument (and major assumption based on Western cultural perspectives, I might add) was that the owners would take care of those assets, invest profits back into them and lift all boats as a result. That didn't happen. The companies were stripped of profits and the money sent offshore. And the people were impoverished. Needless to say that that wasn't useful.

I think the economists had to invent a new stage of development to account for it. Milton Friedman said that he had been one of the loudest with, "Privatize, privatize, privatize!" He now says he was wrong, it should have been, "Rule of law, rule of law, rule of law!" He still has it wrong. It should have been, "Culture, culture, culture!"--a much different problem.

Western companies are profit focused. They will reinvest and that will improve things. Again, it is in their interest to do so, their long-term financial interests to do so.

what about taxes?

Taxes will be paid. It creates too much risk to not pay them and companies don't like that kind of risk.

The real problem is to make sure that the tax system, including collection, is transparent and fair. Tax inspectors here have had a lot of power and corruption is rife among them. It has been common to get a visit from an inspector who holds his hand out, so to speak, as he tells you that you owe more than you have paid. These arrears have a tendency to disappear when the hand is filled...or not if you are a political opponent or someone in the way of a powerful financial interest.

Businesses tend to understate profits to avoid the risks this presents. So they end up keeping two sets of books, one for the inspectors and one for the business itself.

Yuschenko has made tax policy a focus of his administration and rightly so. He wants to entice businesses back to paying their taxes by overhauling the tax administration and making taxes simpler and fairer. That will help a whole lot. He has done some things and is working on others and there is already evidence that what has been done is working--tax revenues are up.

Good questions.

27 comments:

Anonymous said...

Scott, in responding to my post - you have made me feel like a *superstar*!!! Thank you. Really great responses which I agree with which I will mull over (it is not the right time for me right now, for which I profusely apologize to you esp. as you have been so wonderful but I first visited Neeka's blog and I am in an emotional state - absolutely reeling - regarding her coverage of the Beslan anniversary and from the events due to Hurricane Katrina.)
I did forget to mention that in order for businesses to prosper and for investment to flow - the legal system needs a major overhaul - from kicking out corrupt judges to the nittty gritty of administrative code to the Constitution ... BTW is it legal in UA today to discriminate labor based on religion? I guess so - based on following news story - this is not good at all. Labor laws need to be overhauled in this case to = no discrimination period. This is will only add to inter-minority tensions which are already not so great.
http://www.risu.org.ua/eng/kaleidoscope/article%3B2737/
Japan is posed to be a major investor in UA - based on the recent summit and it as with everything else in life - is a double edged sword - Japan is a major investor in Russia - rep. tobacco companies etc. Do you really want to see more ads promoting smoking directed at the youth?
again, my apologies I am shattered by recent events and so my writing may reflect that - but I wanted to thank you from the bottom of my heart for responding and reply. My best to you and yours. I would like to hear an update re: your mother-in-law (awesome woman!!!) I remember vividly your post regarding her trip to Kyiv to see the OR for herself - how is she?
Again, thank you, thank you, thank you, !!!
BTW I miss your views on Putin/Moscow and economic coverage. ;)

Anonymous said...

Great Blog! I wanted to share this with you. Are you tired of the Internet Marketing Rat Race? business home resource which


Check this out when you have time :-)

Anonymous said...

Thats a great view point. I had not really considered it from that perspective before regarding work at home job opportunity. Put it this way, most people who are rich have their own businesses many of which started as a work from home based business. I have an article based webs site discussing such issues as work at home job opportunity which should be an eye opener for most people thinking of starting their own home business. Keep up the great information with your blog.

Anonymous said...

Excellent san diego internet marketing articlre.
Keep up the great san diego internet marketing blog. I find it very informative. I check back soon
Thanks again for a great and informative san diego internet marketing articlre.

Anonymous said...

Hello!
Very interesting blog.
I will make sure to come back often to this blog.
If You really are interested in offshore investing new zealand I can strongly
recommend offshore investing new zealand
Here You can find an almost comlete directory of this subject.

Anonymous said...

While surfing the net looking for Websites similar to my site about free work at home job listing I came across your blog about free work at home job listing It is nice to see that there are people out there who are willing to give us insights into
their daily lives through their blogs.

Anonymous said...

Hey good post. Look at my site if you can. Thanks! free microsoft money download

Anonymous said...

Hey i got here searching for make some extra cash
Your sites not too bad!

You got good rankings for them keywords make some extra cash

I would personally like to ask you to join my site its a forum about making money online , affiliate programs etc... your a good writer , hope to see you there maybe you can learn too how to make extra cash.

Thanks
make some extra cash

Anonymous said...

This is a good post. I have a site about real estate financing please look at it if you can.

Danny White said...

I found a free new home based business opportunity resource blog/site that really helped me
get a handle on new home based business opportunity.

I thought your posters might find this new home based business opportunity resource useful.

new home based business opportunity

Check it out if you get time:-)

Anonymous said...

I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about business computer earn home money related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.

Anonymous said...

I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about fast home make money need related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.

Anonymous said...

Advertising can be a big problem otherwise. A lot of companies reserve a big chunk of their budgets to cover marketing expenditures.

Anonymous said...

GROW IT YOURSELF!

Anonymous said...

Hey blogger do you know that you can make cash from your blog?

Its so simple a child could do it!

This goes for anyone reading this too.

You can make up to $0.40 per visit with this nice affiliate program called Zangocash

Its one of the best programs out there at the minute and can suit any blogger or webmaster!

To sign up and start earning money right away!

Just click this link below
affiliate advertising

So why not start earning today!

Anonymous said...

Hey nice blog!

I want you to come join this site about 1 1 417 adult finder friend

Its cool Adult Friend Finder

Click the 1 1 417 adult finder friend link above and join :) see you there

Anonymous said...

marketing book

Anonymous said...

Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a bad credit mortgage refinance site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Come and check it out if you have time :-)

Anonymous said...

I look forward to Your visit!

Anonymous said...

Excellent adult affiliate related blog. I will add you to my bookmarks.

I have a adult affiliate related site. It covers ##KEYWORD## and other related stuff.

Also have another cool site called HotLinZ

Drop by if you get time :-)

Anonymous said...

Well I have to say that your blog is one of the better one on mlm opportunity phone voip, I will have to book mark your blog. I have a site that is probably the best free generic training course in the industry. If you have time please take a look at mlm opportunity phone voip

Anonymous said...

Great Blog you have here! I am going to bookmark this one....
Have you ever wanted to have the upper hand in casino's?
texas hold em poker
I read some of the books we sell on this site and found out
things I didn't know about. Very informative info. Others sell
these books for $29.95 but I sell them for $9.95.Check this one out :-)texas hold em poker

Anonymous said...

hey did you know you can get a free ipod pretty easily?
just go to www.getipodsforfree.com, sign up and do an offer

Anonymous said...

Hi there, Nice little blog you've got going on there.

Keep it up!

This might interest you if you're after some more web site traffic The contents of this site will explode your hits! Auto surf and recieve 50,000 credits free - Join free! free online traffic jam gamefree online traffic jam game

Anonymous said...

Increase your Search Engine Rank in Days noy Months!

safelists said...

Hi Scott W. Clark, If you would like to make great money online please click here resell right programs, for more info on making The Best Marketing,Resell Right,AutoSurf and Affiliate Programs On The Net http://www.incbizz.com. resell right programs

Anonymous said...

Scott W. Clark, interesting post - this post.

Personally, I've always found to be very intriguing, and interesting, but not always very informative. So I did some research and started my own webpage to help people get started with .

If also piques your interest, come by when you've got a few seconds - check out the different resources listed. I'm sure you'll find it very interesting.